When teachers see a student get upset because the seating plan changed, the schedule shifted, the teacher arrived late, or an activity didn’t start exactly as expected, the common assumptions are:
- “They’re being dramatic.”
- “They’re too sensitive.”
- “They’re stubborn.”
- “They should just adapt.”
- “Everyone else is fine — why are they not?”
But for many neurodivergent learners — especially autistic, ADHD, and anxiety-prone students — rigid routines and a strong need for predictability are not personality flaws.
👉 Predictability is their safety.
Routine is their regulation.
Change feels like losing control.
1. What rigid routines and predictability actually mean
Research on autism (Kanner, 1943; American Psychiatric Association, 2022) shows that sameness and routine help the brain stay calm by:
- reducing sensory overload
- lowering anxiety
- providing structure when the world feels chaotic
- making social expectations clearer
- supporting executive functioning
- preventing shutdowns or meltdowns
Predictability isn’t about being controlling — it’s about avoiding overwhelm.
Even small unexpected changes can feel huge to a dysregulated nervous system.
2. What it looks like in the classroom
Teachers may notice:
- distress when seating changes
- frustration when the teacher skips a step
- anger when the timing of an activity is different
- shutting down when instructions change suddenly
- difficulty moving from one task to the next
- needing to know “what’s next” before starting
- wanting to finish one task fully before switching
- repeating questions about the schedule
- asking for exact times, steps, and order
To others, these reactions seem “over the top.”
But to the student, the change feels unsafe, not just inconvenient.
3. Why ND students react so strongly to change
Because their brains process unpredictability differently in several areas:
Sensory processing
New environments, new noises, new seating = instant overload.
Executive functioning
Transitions require planning, sequencing, and mental shifting — all difficult for autistic/ADHD brains.
Emotional regulation
Unexpected change can trigger panic, fear, or frustration because the brain loses its anchor.
Cognitive load
Routine reduces mental effort; change increases it rapidly.
Social understanding
Predictability helps them understand expectations; sudden changes blur the rules.
What looks like “rigid” behaviour is actually self-protection.
4. Why ESL classrooms intensify this behaviour
ESL lessons involve:
- multiple tasks in one class
- unpredictable speaking activities
- switching between listening, reading, writing
- pair and group work
- new topics every lesson
- rapid instructions
- unclear expectations
- sudden “Your turn!” moments
For neurodivergent students, this constant shifting is exhausting.
So they cling even harder to routines because:
- language learning feels unstable
- classroom noise is unpredictable
- they need structure to process meaning
- they cannot rely on instinctive social cues
- they rely on routine to reduce cognitive pressure
Predictability = less overwhelm = better learning.
5. The biggest misconception: “They just don’t want to adapt.”
This assumes flexibility is a matter of willpower.
It isn’t.
Neurodivergent flexibility is tied to:
- sensory thresholds
- anxiety
- cognitive load
- executive functioning
- need for control in a chaotic world
You can’t “teach flexibility” by surprising them more.
That only increases distress.
6. What NOT to do
Avoid these common mistakes:
❌ “You need to be more flexible.”
→ Shame, not support.
❌ Changing plans without warning
→ Leads to shutdowns or meltdowns.
❌ Publicly calling them out
→ Increases anxiety.
❌ Rushing transitions
→ Overloads their brain.
❌ Assuming they’re being dramatic
→ Damages trust.
7. What teachers SHOULD do
Here are strategies that actually help:
âś” Give advance notice
Even one sentence helps:
“Next week we might change the seating for a group activity.”
âś” Make routines visible
Steps on the board
Daily agenda
Clear timeline
âś” Use consistent structures
Start class the same way
End the same way
Use repeated patterns for instructions
âś” Break transitions into tiny steps
“First close the book.
Then look at me.
Then take out your notebook.”
âś” Explain the reason for changes
It reduces anxiety.
âś” Allow time to adjust
They’re not resisting — they are regulating.
âś” Offer a quiet space
Especially during overwhelming changes.
âś” Validate their feelings
“You didn’t expect this, so it feels uncomfortable. That’s okay.”
Validation does not reinforce the behaviour — it reduces the panic behind it.
8. What rigid routines really mean
Here’s the reality many teachers miss:
🟣 Rigid routines mean the student is trying to stay regulated.
🟣 Predictability is not control — it’s comfort.
🟣 Unexpected change triggers fear, not attitude.
🟣 A predictable class helps them succeed academically and emotionally.
When teachers support predictability, students do not become “more rigid.”
They become less anxious — and more able to participate.
Creative English With Alpcan 